Wednesday 5 May 2010

A modern sophisticated society

Yesterday Kenneth Clarke, the shadow (or 'Tory party') business secretary, warning of the dangers of a hung parliament, told politics.co.uk:
"There would be really quite appalling consequences for this country if we are not able to produce a credible plan for dealing with the deficit and the debt. And that involves some very difficult decisions.

If I have to sit and talk to three or four other groups... in the end you can always do a deal with an Ulsterman, but it's not the way to run a modern sophisticated society in the grips of an economic crisis which weak government under Gordon Brown has already caused."
That pretty much sums up how the DUP and the UUP are seen by the British political elite.

Colonials, not 'us', not really British, and neither modern nor sophisticated.

Will nobody think of the children?

Well, Save the Children will, of course. On Monday they published their 11th annual 'Mothers' Index', which ranks the best and worst places to be a mother. Unsurprisingly, Afghanistan ranked at the bottom of the list of 160 countries – well done to Bush and Blair for helping it to get there!

A lot of attention is given to the 'Top 10': Norway ranks first, followed by Australia, Iceland, Sweden, Denmark, New Zealand, Finland, the Netherlands, Belgium and Germany.

But who is that just under the radar, at number 11? Yes, it is Ireland – the country that is almost Scandinavian, but just not quite.


And the UK? The place that unionists think is a better place than Ireland. Well, it's not too bad, at number 14, but it still isn't as good.

For the good of all of our children, it seems that a united Ireland is better than a United Kingdom – but unionism, for its bigoted reasons, insists on locking a quarter of our country into a backward state. It must be defeated, for the good of all of us, including our children.

Tuesday 4 May 2010

That Belfast Telegraph poll

The Belfast Telegraph has put its flawed poll on the web. The poll, published today, but based on interviews conducted between 22-29 April, is out of date and thus quite pointless. Additionally the sample size was small – 3,200 people across Northern Ireland but less than 200 per constituency.

For what it's worth, though, the poll has the following 'results':

Overall – DUP 26%, Sinn Féin 25%, SDLP 17%, UCUNF 13%, Alliance 7%, independents 6%, TUV 5%, 1%.

Fermanagh and South Tyrone:


The Belfast Telegraph has Michelle Gildernew (44%) slightly ahead of Rodney Connor (43%).

Upper Bann:

John O'Dowd is within 4% of David Simpson.

South Down: Margaret Ritchie (43%) is well ahead of Caitriona Ruane (26%).

East Belfast: an easy win for Peter Robinson (42%) ahead of second-placed Ringland (26%).

North Antrim: Paisley 39%, Allister 31% …

South Antrim: McCrea 36%, Empey 30% …

North Down: an easy win for Sylvia Hermon.

The rest of the seats are reckoned to stay with their incumbents, without any shocks. In fact, if this poll is correct, all the seats will remain in their current party hands. However, to repeat – this is a week-old poll, and based on fairly loose methodology, so its resemblance to reality on Thursday is not likely to be perfect. It disagrees with the evidence of the bookies – who may also not be correct, but their 'results' are what people are prepared to stake their own money on!

Monday 3 May 2010

Paddy Power shows opinion changes

Since last week Paddy Power has recorded some changes in the odds offered in a number of Northern Irish constituencies.

In North Antrim: last week the odds were DUP 4/11, and TUV 15/8; but today they are DUP 1/3 and TUV 2/1. This shows a slight swing in the mind of the punter further towards the DUP.

In South Antrim the odds have completely changed: last week the odds were DUP 5/6 and UCUNF 5/6. Now the odds are UCUNF 4/6 and DUP 11/10. In other words the punter now thinks that Reg Empey will win.

In North Belfast last week the punter thought that Nigel Dodds was a dead cert: the DUP was at 1/4, and Sinn Féin at 11/4. Now, although Dodds is still ahead, the odds have moved slightly towards Sinn Féin – the DUP are on 2/7, and Sinn Féin are on 5/2.

In South Down Margaret Ritchie has weaked a little: last week she was on 1/9, but now she is on 1/7. Caitriona Ruane has shortened from 5/1 to 4/1. It still leaves the SDLP are clear favourites, of course.

In Fermanagh and South Tyrone last week Rodney Connor was on 8/11, and Sinn Féin’s Michelle Gildernew was on evens. Today it’s Rodney Connor on 8/13 and
Michelle Gildernew on 6/5. That represents a strengthening of Connor’s position.

East Derry shows a different type of swing. A week ago the DUP was on 1/6, and the TUV on 10/1 (UCUNF was on 6/1). Today, though, the DUP has slipped to 2/9, and the TUV has strengthened to 7/1 (UCUNF remain on 6/1). So although Gregory Campbell is still very much the favourite, Willie Ross is catching up – but not fast enough.

In Strangford the DUP was on 4/7 a week ago, UCUNF was on 5/4 and the TUV was on 20/1. Today, though, the DUP is on 2/5, UCUNF is on 7/4, and the TUV is on 25/1. So the DUP is increasing its lead here.

Lastly, in Upper Bann, a week ago the DUP was on 4/7, UCUNF was on 9/4, and Sinn Féin was on 8/1. Now the DUP’s odds have slightly shortened to 8/13, UCUNF’s have shortened to 2/1, and Sinn Féin’s have shortened to 7/1. So although the DUP remain favourite to win, all three major parties see their odds improve slightly.

What does it all mean? In short, most seats will remain in their current hands, except for:
  • South Antrim – Empey to win
  • FST – Connor to win
But several other constituencies become closer and thus more interesting to watch – including North Belfast, South Down, East Derry and Upper Bann. If there are to be surprises, they should be in one or other of these constituencies.

Swings and roundabouts (the punters' opinion, part 4)

In the absence of reliable opinion polls, the bookies odds have become an invaluable way of gauging voter sentiment in Northern Ireland. Not an infallible way, of course – only betters' opinions are counted, and it's quite likely that few fundamentalist Christians ever darken the doors of a betting shop.

Nonetheless, it’s the only tool available, so for what it's worth, here are some of the small swings that the odds have shown so far:
  • In South Antrim, William Hill is now showing a slight UCUNF advantage – 8/11, with the DUP on evens. Last week both parties were level-pegged at 5/6.
  • In contrast to that, though, William Hill is showing shorter odds for the DUP in Strangford (i.e. they reckon the chance of the DUP winning is better than it was). Last week Jim Shannon was on 8/13, but today that is 1/2. The chances for the UCUNF candidate, Mike Nesbitt, have lengthened from 6/5 to 6/4.
  • In Fermanagh and South Tyrone, William Hill now have Rodney Connor on 8/11, a slight dis-improvement (but a relative improvement) from last week's 5/6. Michelle Gildernew, who was also on 5/6 last week, has slipped back to evens.
Apart from these three constituencies, the odds quoted by William Hill appear unchanged. Tomorrow this blog will look at how Paddy Power sees things evolving.

No more local by-elections

The Electoral Office has announced, in minimalist terms, that:
Douglas Bain, the Chief Electoral Officer today declared the return of the new councillors to fill the vacancies that arose from the resignation of Nigel Dodds MLA OBE and Diane Dodds MEP.

Sarah Lydia Patterson has been returned in the Castle District Electoral Area whilst Brian Lambert Kingston has been returned in the Court District Electoral Area.

The councillors were returned under the new law that allows the nominating officer for the relevant party to nominate a person to fill a vacancy in a seat previously held by a member of that party.

And thus ends the long and interesting tradition of the local government by-election in Northern Ireland.

The Electoral Law Act (Northern Ireland) 1962 (Amendment) Order 2010 sets out detailed rules for the filling of 'casual vacancies' in district councils – the essential part of which, however, is as follows:
As soon as practicable after receiving the notice of the vacancy the Chief Electoral Officer must ask the nominating officer of that registered party to nominate in writing, within 28 days from the date of the Chief Electoral Officer's request, a person ( “P”) to fill the vacancy.

In other words, when a Councillor resigns or dies, his or her party get to nominate a replacement – and this is the party in whose name he/she stood when last elected, so defected seats return to their original owner. There are other rules for independent Councillors, who can give the Chief Electoral Officer a list of substitutes, from whom the replacement is taken (they are ordered according to preference by the Councillor, and offered the seat in that order).

Where a party no longer exists at the time of the casual vacancy arising, an election can take place, but this will be extremely rare. For the most part, local by-elections are now consigned to history, and with them dies one of the small pleasures of the psephologist.

David Norris for President

The Irish Times has kicked off next year's presidential election by providing a list of the possible candidates, and this blog is pleased to note that the current front-runner is Senator David Norris.


David Norris represents everything that the President should be – a decent, civilised and intelligent man, political but not party political, and with a strong streak of compassion. But he is more than that – much more. He is Ireland's foremost gay rights campaigner, one of the world's leading Joycian scholars, and an active member of the Church of Ireland.

Born in the then Belgian Congo, Norris has been associated with Trinity College for much of his career, and is a well-known figure around Dublin. As such he will struggle to attract the votes of rural Ireland – but in the opinion of this blog, he represents modern Ireland better than any of the has-been politicians that the other parties will propose.

Hopefully Norris will stand, and hopefully modern Ireland will be big enough and tolerant enough to elect not a gay President, not a(nother) Protestant President, but a President that represents the full diversity of the nation.

Norris for President in 2011.